Italian Catering in New York City
Elevate your event with the authentic flavors of Italy through CaterCow's curated Italian catering. From gourmet pizzas to delectable pastas, we bring the heart of Italian cuisine to your table, making every gathering unforgettable.
Too busy to meal plan? We can set up an office meal program just for you!
Italian Packages
Browse 43 Italian Packages from our restaurant partners based in New York City. Each of them have been hand-curated by our team to make ordering for your group a breeze!
Allow Us To Introduce Ourselves
We thoughtfully curate every option you see. We believe that food can inspire, spark conversation and bring people together. Our goal is to offer the best food for your group in a convenient-to-use, easy-to-order format.
What is CaterCow?
We’re an online catering marketplace featuring vetted menus designed to work for groups large and small.
Food with personality.
No more uninspired sandwich boxes. Pick from unique, seasonal options curated by our team.
Easy to use.
We’ve streamlined the process for ordering food for your group, just the click of a button and your job is done.
CaterCow is hands down the greatest company I've ever worked with. Ever.
I feel like I'm their only customer. Any issue that may arise with a vendor is swiftly met with dedicated acumen, poise, and accommodation. I've seen them make immediate changes to their website based on a mistake I myself made. If I could have the whole team over for dinner, I would. Every single person I've connected with has felt like a friend. Show me another organization anywhere, let alone a catering company, that offers that level of personal attention. I'll wait.
Too busy? Try Managed.
If you order catering frequently and would prefer for us to handle menu selection, we can set you up with a dedicated account manager. Your point of contact will send you weekly menus for approval and handle all coordination with restaurants. If interested, please fill out the provided form and we will get back to you with further details!
Tips for Ordering Italian Catering (Including Pizza)
Italian cuisine is a beloved choice for catering events, offering a rich variety of flavors that can please just about any palate. Whether you're planning a corporate event, a wedding, or a casual gathering, Italian catering—especially with the inclusion of pizza—can elevate the experience. Here are some tips to ensure your Italian catering order is a success.
1. Know Your Audience
Before placing your order, consider the preferences and dietary restrictions of your guests. Italian cuisine is versatile, offering everything from vegetarian options to gluten-free dishes. Ask your caterer about options like gluten-free pasta, vegetarian pizzas, and dairy-free sauces. If you’re unsure, consider ordering a mix of dishes to accommodate everyone.
2. Choose a Variety of Dishes
Italian food goes beyond just pizza and pasta. Include a variety of appetizers such as bruschetta, antipasto platters, and Caprese salad. For mains, consider offering a selection of pizzas, pastas, and protein-based dishes like chicken parmigiana or veal scaloppine. Don’t forget to include some traditional Italian desserts like tiramisu, cannoli, or panna cotta to end the meal on a sweet note.
3. Consider Portion Sizes
When ordering for a group, it’s important to get the portion sizes right. Discuss with your caterer how many guests you’re expecting and whether the meal will be served buffet-style or plated. If you’re serving pizza, consider offering a variety of sizes (individual, medium, large) depending on the event’s nature. A good rule of thumb is to order a bit more than you think you'll need—Italian leftovers are never a bad thing!
4. Timing is Everything
Italian food is best when it’s fresh and hot, especially pizza. Work with your caterer to ensure the food is delivered just before it’s time to eat. If the event is lengthy or staggered, consider options that can be easily reheated or served at room temperature without losing flavor or quality.
5. Don’t Forget the Beverages
Italian cuisine pairs beautifully with a variety of beverages. If your event allows, consider offering a selection of wines—think Chianti, Pinot Grigio, or Prosecco. For non-alcoholic options, Italian sodas, sparkling water, and fresh lemonade are great choices. Coffee or espresso can be a delightful way to complement dessert.
6. Presentation Matters
Italian food is as much about presentation as it is about taste. Talk to your caterer about how the food will be presented. For formal events, consider plated dishes with elegant garnishes. For casual gatherings, rustic bread baskets, charcuterie boards, and pizza stands can create a more relaxed, authentic atmosphere.
By keeping these tips in mind, you can ensure that your Italian catering experience is smooth, delicious, and memorable for all your guests. Buon appetito!