Important, please read. Due to delivery logistics, Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery will deliver your order within a 2-hour window. The delivery time you choose will be the tail end of the 2-hour window (e.g. if you choose 3:00 pm, your delivery window will be 1:00-3:00 pm). Thank you for understanding!

It's My Party and I Want Cake

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
By Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
  • 365 Grand St, New York, NY 10002

5.0 (1 review)

100% Recent Order Success Rate

0 issues in the last 21 orders

Celebrating a promotion, retirement, or office birthday? Design a custom cake perfect for any occasion!
Sustainability Measures
✊🏿✊✊🏾✊🏼

Menu: $5.85

Staff Pick

To add an inscription to the cake, message us after placing your order with your preferred cake inscription.

Menu checked for nuts.

Unless an item is explicitly tagged with (N), everything else on this menu is nut free.

Disclaimer: restaurant carries nuts, so there is risk of cross contamination.

Choice of Sheet Cakes

Each sheet cake is 12x18

1 Sheet Cake serves 30 people

  • Vanilla Cake + Chocolate Buttercream + White Border V

Or Build Your Own

1 Cake Flavor
1 Icing Flavor
1 Border Color

Choice of Cake Flavor

Choose 1

  • Vanilla Cake V
  • Chocolate Cake V
  • Red Velvet Cake V

Choice of Icing Flavor

Choose 1

  • White Vanilla Buttercream V GF
  • Chocolate Buttercream V GF
  • White Whipped Buttercream V GF
  • Pink Vanilla Buttercream V GF
  • Yellow Vanilla Buttercream V GF
  • Blue Vanilla Buttercream V GF

Choice of Border Color

Choose 1

  • White Border V GF
  • Pink Border V GF
  • Yellow Border V GF
  • Blue Border V GF

Not What You Were Looking For?

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Catering Reviews

4 Star (9)
1 Star (0)

Recent Reviews

Menu Rating

It's My Party and I Want Cake

(1)

Eunice V.

Mar, 2025

Reviewing Fresh Baked Mini Pies

5 stars

Doriann W.

Mar, 2025

Reviewing Superstar Cupcakes

5 stars

Hayley P.

Feb, 2025

Reviewing Mini Cupcake Madness

5 stars

David M.

Dec, 2024

Reviewing Frosty Holiday Cookies

5 stars

Daniel V.

Nov, 2024

Reviewing Fresh Baked Mini Pies

5 stars

Jeffrey C.

Nov, 2024

Reviewing Fresh Baked Mini Pies

5 stars

N'Dea R.

Nov, 2024

Reviewing Fresh Baked Mini Pies

5 stars

Amanda D.

Nov, 2024

Reviewing a la carte order

Us teachers & mom to be loved the cupcakes! Thank you for dyeing them blue & for helping to get this done in time for the surprise event!

Mervin M.

Nov, 2024

Reviewing Fresh Baked Mini Pies

5 stars

Luna D.

Nov, 2024

Reviewing Fresh Baked Mini Pies

5 stars

$5.85/Person

Presentation Style

Buffet
Individual
Please enter your delivery address to continue.